In recent years, Otterbein graduates have been admitted to the following law schools:

• University of Michigan
• Duke University
• The Ohio State University
• American University
• Wake Forest University
• Depaul University
• University of Toledo
• University of Dayton
• Capital University
• University of Cincinnati
• Ohio Northern University
• McGeorge Law School in Sacramento
• Dickinson Law School in Pennsylvania
• Cleveland Marshall College of Law
• Massachusetts School of Law
• Detroit College of Law
• Loyola University of Chicago.