The Sky was Blue on Sept. 11, 2001

The Sky was Blue on Sept. 11, 2001

Twenty-five years after the events of Sept. 11, 2001, Otterbein hosted events on campus to provide community for those who remember that tragic day and historical perspective and personal insight for students who know 9/11 primarily through textbooks and documentaries. Early in the week, students, faculty, staff, and alumni were invited to help place 2,977 flags on the lawn in front of Towers Hall, one representing each victim of the attacks, and their country of origin.

At a campus remembrance event held on Sept. 10, Director of Choral Activities Gayle Walker led the Concert Choir in a performance on campus. Before they sang, Walker shared her reflection of leading members of Otterbein’s Concert Choir at a fundraiser at Ohio Stadium on Saturday, Sept. 15, 2001. Also at the 25th remembrance event, Willie Franklin ’10, staff emeritus, shared reflections from campus; senior lecturer Maria Tarbell shared reflections from Washington, D.C.; and theatre lighting design professor TJ Gerckens ’88 and his wife, Stephanie Haney Gerckens ’87, shared their reflections from New York City and central Ohio, respectively.

On Friday, Sept. 11, many members of the Otterbein community joined the Westerville Fire and Police Divisions, VFW/American Legion, and other residents at the annual City of Westerville remembrance gathering at First Responders Park. Just steps from campus on Main Street, the park is built around artifact C-40, a piece of steel from the North Tower.

Letter from President Comerford, Fall 2026

Cardinals,

Fall is a wonderful time to be on a college campus. Students and faculty are back and hard at work in classrooms, labs, and on the playing fields. Parking lots are full, and the Cardinal’s Nest is busy. Otterbein is excited to welcome nearly 750 new first-year, adult, and transfer students to campus this fall.

Those students arrive on a campus that is significantly changed after the retirement of two Otterbein legends. Professor Joan Rocks, who developed the Athletic Training program at Otterbein and built the Department of Health and Sport Sciences, retired after serving Otterbein for 34 years. And George “Skip” Ford, after impacting the lives of thousands of Otterbein athletes in his role as athletic facilities supervisor/equipment administrator, retired after 32 years. Both Joan and Skip shaped Otterbein through their hard work, their care, and their commitment to serving others.

READY is another program that sets Otterbein apart from other universities. READY is the only four-year career and professional development program in the state of Ohio in which participation is required to graduate. The most visible part of the program is READY Day, when classes are cancelled and offices are closed so all faculty, staff, and students can participate in an on-campus career development conference. Students are required to participate in immersive, high-impact practice like internships, research and creative work, study abroad, significant leadership activity, or community service. And the program works — 100% of seniors who participated in the National Survey of Student Engagement reported completing an immersive experience. Even more amazing, 90% of seniors reported completing two such experiences, significantly more than our private university peers in the Great Lakes regions.

The Church of the Master celebrates its 175th anniversary this fall. Otterbein and the Church (first known as Otterbein Station) have a history and future that are intertwined. The supportive relationship continues to strengthen. Associate Pastor Lucy Kelly also serves as Otterbein’s director of faith and spiritual life and is making a huge impact on campus while the Church membership provides funds for students in need, special events, and free coffee and donuts every Monday morning!

President John Comerford is pictured here with Nevalyn Fritsche Nevil ’71 and Floyd Akins, vice president for philanthropy and alumni engagement

President John Comerford is pictured here with Church of the Master Senior Pastor Katya Brodbeck. Comerford spoke at the church’s 175th celebration and presented a gift from Otterbein that was created at the Point in the Maker Space. The inscription reads: “Praeterita et Futura Nexa (from Latin, “the past and the future are interconnected”). Presented on this 27th Day of September, 2026 on the Occasion of the Church’s 175th Anniversary.”

Finally, Otterbein celebrated another great Homecoming Weekend. It is wonderful to welcome our alumni back to campus. We had a great 50th Reunion celebration for the Class of 1976.

 

With Cardinal pride,

John L. Comerford, Ph.D.

Interview with Melissa Dawn Simkins ’99

Interview with Melissa Dawn Simkins ’99

Recently, AJ Najy ’27, an English and Music Performance major with a minor in Women’s, Gender, and Sexuality Studies had the opportunity to interview Melissa Dawn Simkins ’99, author of the Athleadership program and the new book Athleadership: The Elite Athletic Mindset: How to Lead Under Pressure and Perform When It Counts.

Class of 1999 Public Relations &communications Major

Q.What did your time at Otterbein look like? Which clubs, classes, and/or hobbies did you participate in? What are your favorite memories?

A.During my time at Otterbein, I enjoyed being involved in many aspects of campus life. I was a member of PRSSA, the Public Relations Student Society of America, and became a member of Delta Sigma Theta Sorority, Inc., Nu Phi Chapter.

I also received a scholarship through a community service grant that allowed me to spend significant time working with the Indianola Middle School mentoring program. That remains one of my most meaningful experiences. We had the opportunity to mentor students in Columbus and give them greater access, encouragement and a vision for what college life could look like. At the same time, we learned just as much about service, responsibility, and the impact we could have on someone else’s future.

I also worked throughout college and completed internships with Victoria’s Secret and Nationwide Insurance. Those experiences gave me an early opportunity to connect what I was learning in the classroom to the real world.

Q.Tell me about your book. What inspired you to write it?

A.Athleadership: The Elite Athletic Mindset: How to Lead Under Pressure and Perform When It Counts came from my own journey of discovering that when life puts on the pressure, you can either break or build.

I have always seen myself as an athlete, not simply because of a sport I played, but because of the mindset. That mindset helped me navigate setbacks, uncertainty, loss, and some of the most demanding moments of my career and life.

Over the last two decades, I’ve also had the opportunity to work alongside CEOs, Fortune 500 leaders, elite athletes, and entrepreneurs. What became clear to me is that the highest performers don’t simply rise to important moments. They condition themselves for them.

My vision for Athleadership is to give anyone the ability to think, feel, decide and perform at their best when it counts most. The world often tells us leaders are born. I believe they are built.

Q.What are a few ways your Otterbein education helped you to write your book?

A.I studied public relations and communications with a minor in business, so there is a very direct connection between what I learned at Otterbein and the work I do today.

Professors such as Dr. Denise Shively challenged me to understand not only how to write, but how to communicate an idea so that someone else could see it, feel it and act on it. I learned to think about audience, message and the responsibility that comes with communication.

Otterbein also gave me room to find my voice. That became incredibly important later as an entrepreneur, speaker, and ultimately an author. Writing a book isn’t simply about having something to say. It’s about learning how to communicate an idea clearly enough that it can become meaningful to someone else.

Q.What advice would you give to a student interested in your field of work?

A.Don’t spend all of your energy trying to figure out the perfect career. Spend more time becoming the person who will be ready when an opportunity appears.

Build relationships before you need them. Ask questions. Take the internship. Volunteer for the assignment that scares you a little. Get in rooms where you aren’t the smartest or most experienced person yet and pay attention.

And don’t underestimate the value of being someone people can count on. Talent may get you noticed, but your ability to deliver, adapt, communicate and build trust is what creates a career.

Your first job doesn’t have to reveal your entire future. Mine didn’t. But every experience can give you another rep toward becoming who you are capable of being.

Q.You’ve worked extensively with Fortune 500 companies, athletes and entrepreneurs while also working as a CEO and entrepreneur yourself. What are some common misconceptions about leadership that you have encountered?

A.One of the biggest misconceptions is that leadership is a position or something you automatically become when you receive a title.

Leadership is a response.

You discover a lot more about someone’s leadership when the plan changes, the pressure rises, the answer isn’t obvious, and other people are looking to them for direction.

Another misconception is that knowing how to lead means you will automatically be able to do it when the pressure is on. Knowledge matters, but access matters more. Can you access what you know when you’re tired, uncertain, challenged or under pressure?

That’s one of the lessons elite athletes understand exceptionally well. You don’t wait until game day to decide how you’re going to perform. You condition the response long before the moment arrives.

Q.What do you hope readers gain from Athleadership?

A.I want people to finish the book seeing themselves differently.

Not everyone will be an athlete, but anyone can become an athleader. To me, an  athleader is someone who is willing to condition themselves to meet the moment in front of them.

I want readers to understand that resilience, agility, alignment and wellbeing aren’t fixed traits that some people have and others don’t. They can be practiced. They can be conditioned.

Ultimately, I want someone to close the book believing, “I can build this.” Because the moments that matter most rarely give us advance notice. The work we do before those moments determines who shows up when they arrive.

Q.What led you to become a trustee at Otterbein after graduating? What was your favorite part of serving as a trustee, and how did this experience influence your career?

A.Otterbein invested in me at an important stage of my life, so serving as a trustee was an opportunity to invest back into an institution that had helped shape me.

What I valued most was being able to see the university from a completely different vantage point. As a student, you experience the university through your classes, friendships, and campus life. As a trustee, you begin to understand the decisions, stewardship, strategy and leadership required to ensure an institution continues serving generations of students.

It reinforced something that has carried throughout my career: leadership requires you to think beyond yourself. You have to consider the people who are here today while also making decisions for people you may never meet.

And it was meaningful to return to Otterbein not simply as a graduate, but to invest in students in particular.

Q.Was there a particular experience or athlete that helped shape your philosophy of applying the mindset of elite athletes to leadership?

A.There wasn’t one athlete or one moment. It was a pattern I kept seeing.

Throughout my career, I’ve had the privilege of working with and around elite performers in sports and business. What fascinated me wasn’t simply what they did when everyone was watching. It was what happened before that.

The preparation. The repetition. The recovery. The coaching. The film study. The willingness to practice something over and over so that when the pressure arrived, the response was already there.

Then I would walk into organizations and see talented leaders facing their own high-pressure moments, but we often approached their preparation very differently. We gave leaders information and expected performance. Athletes would never prepare that way.

That gap became the foundation for Athleadership.

Elite athletes don’t become elite because someone told them what great performance looks like. They condition for it. I believe leaders can do the same.

Celebrating Alumni Excellence and Generosity

Celebration of Otterbein

Celebration Of Otterbein

The accomplishments of several alumni were highlighted at the 2026 Celebration of Otterbein Awards held during Homecoming weekend in September. Congratulations to the following alumni and friends:

Rising Star Award
Gigi Howard Levey ’20
Shaquille Alexander ’18

Otterbein Alumni Award
Erin Stewart Miller ’97

Distinguished Alumni Award
Randy Adams ’76

Honorary Alumni Award
Alan Borer H’26

Service to Otterbein Award
Lois Augenstein Harris ’63

Mary B. Thomas ’28 Commitment to Otterbein Award

Nevalyn Nevil ’71

Dee Hoty '74

Gigi Howard Levey ’20

Dee Hoty '74

Shaquille Alexander ’18

Dee Hoty '74

Erin Stewart Miller ’97

Dee Hoty '74

Randy Adams ’76

Dee Hoty '74

Alan Borer H’26

Dee Hoty '74

Lois Augenstein Harris ’63

Learn more about the honorees or nominate someone for a 2027 award at www.otterbein.edu/alumni/awards.

2026 Athletics Hall of Fame Honorees

Julie Russell Summer Reunion Group Picture

Otterbein Athletics welcomed its 18th Hall of Fame class in October. The Otterbein Athletics Hall of Fame was established in 2008 to honor individuals and teams that have made significant contributions to the success of our programs, either as athletes or in supporting roles.

The 2026 inductees are:

• Gerry D’Arcy, men’s soccer coach, 1989-2016

• Mike Grayem ’66, men’s basketball

• Bill Hillier ’79, football and baseball

• Wes Meadows ’13, baseball

The 2025 inductees are:

• Steven Schnarr ’75, football

• Markita (May) Suttle ’03, track and field

• Ed Syguda, Cardinal Achievement Citation

Thank You for Giving Back

On behalf of the Office of Alumni Engagement, thank you to the more than 125 alumni who shared their time and expertise with current Otterbein students at READY Day on Sept. 23. Keynote speakers were Maggie Ellison ’10, MBA’19, Adam Rothermel ’06, and Melissa Dawn Simkins ’99.

Maggie Ellison ’10, MBA’19

Adam Rothermel ’06

Melissa Dawn Simkins ’99

Welcome to the Nest

The Division of Philanthropy and Alumni Engagement is pleased to welcome two new team members whose experience, enthusiasm, and dedication will help strengthen connections with the University’s alumni, donors, and friends.

Molly Hagan
Coordinator of Alumni Engagement

Adam Walker

Adam Walker
Annual Giving Program Coordinator

Historical Markers Debut on Otterbein’s Campus

Julie Russell Summer Reunion Group Picture

Led by local historian, alumnus, and Otterbein registrar emeritus Don Foster ’73, a new historical marker was recently erected to honor Benjamin Hanby, class of 1858. Hanby enrolled at Otterbein in 1849 and alternated college terms with teaching in nearby public schools to pay his tuition. Among his many accomplishments, he composed the antislavery ballad Darling Nelly Gray in 1856, as well as the beloved holiday favorite Up on the Housetop in 1864. Hanby died in 1867 and is buried in Otterbein Cemetery. The marker is located on Grove Street, just north of Cowan Hall.

Otterbein also dedicated a new marker at Homecoming honoring Otterbein’s first Black graduate William Henry Fouse, class of 1893. Fouse worked as a bootblack and waiter to pay his college tuition and graduated cum laude. The idea for the marker came from Frank Dobson Jr., Ph.D., Otterbein’s former chief diversity officer who retired in May 2025. Dobson wanted to ensure students understood this important part of Otterbein’s history and Fouse’s significance. Working with University Archivist Stephen Grinch ’98 and longtime volunteer Alan Borer H’26, the group spent several months researching and preparing the marker proposal for the Ohio History Connection. The marker stands on Center Street behind the William Henry Fouse House of Black Culture, 154 W. Home St., near the site of the Hanby House, which was owned and occupied by the Fouse family.

L to R: Rev. Lucy Kelly, Stephen Grinch ’98, John Comerford, Dezmon Howard ’27 and Phanawn Bailey ’21, MBA’23

Cardinal Couple Renews Vows

Julie Russell Summer Reunion Group Picture

Ben Leffel ’10 and Dani Webster-Leffel ’10 met as freshmen in 2006, instantly becoming friends during orientation and remaining inseparable until graduating in 2010. Little did they know how their paths would continue to intertwine over the next two decades.

On Christmas 2025, Ben proposed to Dani at the Alum Creek Park Amphitheater, a spot they had been visiting together since 2006. They were married at the amphitheater on Aug. 15, 2026, in a ceremony officiated by their favorite professor, Candy Canzoneri. A camera battery failure left them with very few photos of the ceremony itself. To capture those moments properly, they returned to the amphitheater with a photographer on Sept. 26 to renew their vows. As a special touch, Dani surprised Ben during Homecoming with a personalized Donor Garden sign on Towers Lawn.

Fun Fact: During his time at Otterbein, Ben was Cardy the Cardinal!

A New Chapter in Alumni Leadership Begins

Julie Russell Summer Reunion Group Picture

Front row: Helene Mundrick Wirth ’99 (chair), Grant Seredick ’17, MSAH ’19 (vice-chair) Middle row: Haylie Schmoll ’19, Todd Thomas ’10, AJ Moffitt ’23, Maria Slovikovski ’17 Back row: Sonya Lowmiller Higginbotham ’98, Wesley Thorne ’96, and Josh Plichta ’18. Members not pictured are Tylina Burdell ’18, Allison Fritchen ’21, Rob Gagnon ’87, Julia Grimm ’22, Deborah Lewis ’77, Madison Moore ’20, Joe Schneider ’00, Emily Steinberg ’22, Duncan Squillante ’21, and Nick Wiseman ’18.

The Office of Alumni Engagement recently launched the Otterbein Alumni Leadership Council (ALC) following a year of research, focus groups, and reenvisioning the former Alumni Council and affiliated alumni boards and networks. The ALC held its inaugural meeting in July 2026.

The new group, led by chair Helene Mundrick Wirth ’99, MBA’03, will engage Otterbein alumni by strengthening connections among Cardinals and advancing a culture of philanthropy for generations to come. Members of the ALC will advocate for a diverse range of programs and initiatives including, but not limited to, athletics, fraternity and sorority life, academic departments, and more, based on their own experiences while students at Otterbein and focus on outreach to fellow alumni.

As the ALC’s representative to the Otterbein Board of Trustees, Sonya Lowmiller Higginbotham ’98 will serve as a vital link between alumni and University leadership, taking alumni feedback, perspectives, and recommendations to the decision-making table.

Thank you to the ALC members for their commitment to strengthening the Cardinal network and shaping the future of alumni engagement at Otterbein.

Class of 1996 30th Reunion

Julie Russell Summer Reunion Group Picture

Front Row (l to r): Stacie Kish Collins, Becky Herbert Cheney, Amy Wagner Wilford, Russ Beitzel, B.C. Wehman Back Row (l to r): Ryan Hickey, Wesley Thorne, Andy Tinkham, Tri Miller, Carlos Marshall, Mark Buckingham, Tania Krochmaluk Smiley, Chris Smiley, Renee De Lozier Jordan, Joe Whitlach, Kris Gossett, Phil Steele, Brandon Beyor (friend of a ’96 classmate), Rob Wilson, and Jodi West Zellers.

The Class of 1996 came together to celebrate its 30th reunion with a dinner at Carfagna’s in Columbus. During Homecoming weekend, classmates also enjoyed a memorable trip to Schneider’s for a donut run while reconnecting on campus.